Skip to main content
Legal news

Tribunal rules dinner lady unfairly dismissed

Jonathan Winston Jonathan Winston
2 min read

A tribunal has ruled that a school dinner lady was unfairly dismissed after she told a couple their seven-year-old daughter had been bullied.

Carol Hill was working at Great Tey Primary School in Essex when she witnessed Chloe David, tied to a fence and being whipped with a skipping rope by four boys. The school’s head teacher wrote to Chloe’s parents after the incident but only referred to Chloe suffering a minor injury with a skipping rope, not mentioning that she had been bullied.

However, Mrs Hill saw Chloe’s mother at a scout meeting later and told her what she had witnessed. She then gave a written statement to the family which was passed on to the police. When the school found out, she was suspended for breaching pupil confidentiality and was later sacked for telling a local paper about the case.

Mrs Hill said that she had been made a scapegoat and had been sacked as part of a “cover-up”. The head teacher, Deborah Crabb, said that Chloe had been playing a game of “prisoners and guards” which had gone too far and that the boys in question had been dealt with. She said that she had recommended that the school governors dismiss Mrs Hill for gross misconduct because she had discussed the incident out of school.

A remedy hearing will be held on 2 February to determine whether Mrs Hill will get her job back or be granted compensation.

More Winston Solicitors news

Client feedback

We can highly recommend the services provided. Our solicitor was extremely thorough and professional and we were always assured that matters were being dealt with in timely manner. Winston Solicitors conveyancing services were recommended to us and we were very satisfied. If we need any further legal assistance in the future we will not hesitate to use them again.
Julia
I do not think that the service we received could be improved. We were treated like friends rather than clients - December 2025
David B, Leeds
Can’t thank Stacey enough, she was very professional and very helpful. - December 2025
Anonymous, Portsmouth
Sam and Paulo were just wonderful. Communications were clear and timely and they were always very professional. A pleasure to deal with, thank you! - December 2025
Sally A, Knaresborough
We have used Winston solicitors before in Particular Samantha the experience on each occasion was friendly and Professional - December 2025
V Wood, Kent
Great experience throughout with Olivia. Good communication and a simple process during my house purchase.Highly recommend Winston Solicitors.
Anonymous
Excellent service and great communication between client and customer. Highly satisfied customer and always dealt with dignity at all times.
Amy
Winston Solicitors were unbelievably helpful with my purchase of my new home. They were on the ball every step of the way and they were always ready to help whenever it was needed. Highly recommend
Jack
Contact us