Skip to main content

Directors and insolvency – where do you stand?

It has been settled law for many years that as a company approached insolvency there was a point when the interests of the creditors became paramount. From this point forward the directors are in danger of creating a personal liability for any additional loss suffered by the company and creditors.

Producing a test that defined the moment when creditor’s interest duty engaged has always been problematical for judges.

This issue reared its head again in the case of BTI AT Industries PLC v Sequana SA (“Sequana”) a decision of the Court of Appeal handed down on 6th February 2019. The forum in this case was that of section 423 of the Insolvency Act 1986. This section of the Act permits the Court to review and overturn transactions designed to put assets beyond the reach of creditors.

Section 423 of Act provides a cause of action, under the heading of “Transactions defrauding creditors”.  This heading can be misleading as it is not in fact necessary to show a dishonest or fraudulent purpose in order to establish a claim under s423. 

Two requirements must be established:

  1. The claimant must show that a person (a company or individual) has entered into a transaction at undervalue.  This will include an outright gift, or a transaction in which the consideration received was significantly less than that given.
  2. The claimant must show that the transaction was entered into for the purpose of putting assets beyond the reach of creditors or future creditors, or otherwise prejudicing their interests.  The purpose need not be the sole purpose, or even the dominant purpose. It is sufficient to show that the purpose of avoiding creditors was at least one of the substantial purposes of the transaction.  It is not necessary that the creditors in question be in existence at the time the transaction is entered into.

The relief available to a successful claimant will be orders restoring the position to what it would have been but for the transaction.  The court’s discretion in terms of relief is wide, and can (subject to a “good faith” exception) include orders against any third party that has received a benefit as a result of the transaction. A very significant liability can result.

The Court of Appeal decided that the duty arises when the directors know or should know that the company is or is likely to become insolvent (which probably means cash flow insolvent). ‘Likely’, for these purposes, means more probable and not some lower test.

The fact that the facts were exceptional does not meant that the test will not apply in more routine circumstances. It will also apply in wrongful trading claims. This is a case with real practical consequences for directors in all companies in financial difficulty.

If you require legal assistance for dealing with insolvency please contact us by email djb@winstonsolicitors.co.uk or call 0113 218 5423.

Client feedback

Winston Solicitors were very professional and helpful at every stage in helping me get letter of administration to help my father. Would highly recommend them
Stephen
My experience was amazing. Always very quick respond and always very helpfull.
Anna
Michelle was brilliant, very professional, responsive, and totally on the ball. Highly recommend Winston Solicitors.
Alex
We contracted Winstons to set up our wills and powers of attorney, and were very pleased with the service. Emily Spencer could not have been more helpful. Highly recommended.
Mr & M
I received an excellent service from Samira and Aminah. They were both professional, approachable and supportive throughout, taking the time to explain everything clearly and ensuring I felt informed at every stage. Their communication was excellent, and I always felt that I was in safe hands. I wouldn't hesitate to recommend their services.
Anonymous
I cannot thank Sidra Razaq enough for the outstanding support she provided throughout my house purchase. From start to finish, she made what could have been a stressful and complicated process feel smooth, straightforward and hassle-free.Sidra was incredibly professional, friendly, approachable and easy to communicate with. Her service was fast, reliable and efficient, and she kept everything on track while ensuring that every detail was carefully checked and nothing was overlooked. She went above and beyond to make sure everything was completed correctly and that I was kept informed throughout the entire process.It was reassuring to know that I was in such capable hands. Sidra genuinely cares about her clients and takes the time to make sure everything is done properly.I would highly recommend Sidra to anyone looking to purchase a property. If you want a solicitor who is professional, reliable, supportive and makes the whole experience as stress-free as possible, Sidra is definitely the person to go to.Thank you again, Sidra, for making my house purchase such a positive experience ❤️
Anonymous
Heidi is 1 of the friendliest and most easy to talk to and understand exactly what Is going on step by step!i am so happy I choose Winston Solicitors and would highly recommend to anybody !
Mark
We were recommended to Winston Solicitors by our financial adviser in order to update our Wills and Lasting Powers of Attorney. From the outset, the members of staff at Winston’s were both welcoming and friendly, and Emily, our appointed solicitor, was very helpful in explaining and helping us to follow the procedures that were required. If we had any concerns or difficulties with any of the issues raised, she was always there to answer our queries. In light of our experience, we would readily recommend Winston Solicitors to our friends. Lennie & Joan Jeffers.
Lennie
Contact David