Naked sleepwalker wins libel case | Winston Solicitors Skip to main content
Legal news

Naked sleepwalker wins libel case

Jonathan Winston Jonathan Winston
2 min read

An Irish businessman has won a libel case against his employer after it claimed that he had made inappropriate advances to a female colleague.

Donal Kinsella sued Kenmare Resources, a mining company based in Dublin, following a press release the firm issued claiming that when on an African business trip in 2007, he had made the advances. Kenmare issued the statement in an attempt to justify its decision to ask Mr Kinsella to step down from his job as chairman of its audit committee. In it they said that “something juicy” had taken place on the business trip, strongly suggesting that his conduct had been inappropriate.

The allegations were that Kinsella had been sleepwalking naked and went to the bedroom door of the firm’s secretary Deidre Corcoran three times, but each time was told to go back to his own bed. The jury at Ireland’s supreme court heard that Kinsella had been drinking and had taken painkillers. However solicitors for the company, after investigating the incident, found that Kinsella had made no attempt to enter Miss Corcoran’s bedroom and there was no evidence of improper conduct.

The supreme court awarded Mr Kinsella €10m in damages, an amount five times bigger than any previous libel case in Ireland. Kenmare Resources has said that it will appeal.

https://www.theguardian.com/law/2010/nov/18/naked-sleepwalker-record-libel-payout

More Winston Solicitors news

Client feedback

We couldn’t recommend Samantha Robertson-Strong enough. She made the whole process of buying our first property so much easier and would recommend her to people I know.Thanks Again Samantha and the Winstons team!
Mr Atherton
Joe and Amr were good at keeping contact and answering my questions as a first time buyer. The solicitor on the other side of the purchase was not always responsive, though Joe/Amr made sure to keep chasing which I appreciated. Overall smooth process and would recommend.
Amber
Absolutely incredible! Exceeded all expectations, very professional.
Michael
It is probably 45+ years since I last bought a house so it was a real re-learning process. Michelle was helpful and pateint throughout. She kept me fully informed of the prgress being made and all the responses from her enquiries to the other party were detailed. Both sides were under pressure to complete before April when further tax increases loomed. It was also the pressure that I would be heading to France to oversee the sale of my property. The only 'blip' that I saw was the query of my funding. It was simply the transfer of the funds from the sale of my home in France to cover the sale in Leeds. This was accepted. I had requested Sterling and not Euros and perhaps that did raise an eyebrow or two. I would have no rpblem in recommending Winstons.
Roger
Outstanding from start to finish. Leasa was fabulous, professional and thorough throughout. Would highly recommend to anyone. We honestly cannot Thankyou enough for getting us into our family home.
Natalie
Winston solicitors are experts at what they do. They go above and beyond the normal service to provide you with the best interest for you. I cannot thank Emily for her commitment and resilience on answering every question i had asked. She is a great assest ti Winston solicitors and a credit to her team. I would love to work with Emily again in the furture if required to do so. Would not hesiste to reccommend winston solicitors to everyone.
Ishtiaq
Amazing service from Sidraa with support from Tom. Timely communication, easy to deal with and thorough. Sidraa went over and above to meet our deadlines and was so personable to deal with. Would 100% recommend.
Sophie
Both Samantha and Michelle at Winstons Solicitors have been brilliant keeping us informed with the selling and buying of our houses. If there were any problems they explained what was happening and also put our minds at rest.... as moving is stressful enough.will definitley use again in the future as we were impressed with the company and service.
Craig
Contact Jonathan