Legal news

Man successfully sues in sex discrimination case

Jonathan Winston Jonathan Winston
2 min read

Eversheds has been ordered to pay £123,000 in a rare case of a man claiming sex discrimination.

John de Belin, an associate at the firm’s property division in Leeds was one of two facing redundancy with the other, Angela Reinholz being on maternity leave. In deciding who to retain, the firm assessed the two of them for their financial performance, discipline history and absence records and Mr de Belin was sacked after losing the exercise by just half a point.

However, he later found out that the test score had been ‘unfairly inflated’ in Mrs Reinholz’s favour. Eversheds awarded her a maximum score, even though she was on maternity leave and justified the decision by saying that any other decision would have deprived her of the opportunity to show that she could have scored the maximum, leaving the firm open to a possible sexual discrimination claim from her.

Mr de Belin himself bought a claim at the Leeds Employment Tribunal for sex discrimination, which found that Eversheds’ way of marking had tipped the balance in Mrs Reinholz’s favour. In the judgement Judge Jeremy Shulman said that it “had the effect of depriving Mr de Belin of his livelihood. We therefore find that Eversheds discriminated against Mr de Belin on the grounds of his sex.”

The redundancy came at a time when Eversheds was cutting staff levels across Britain. Mr de Belin had worked with the firm for 14 years and earned around £100,000. Mrs Reinholz is thought to have earned about the same but had worked fewer years.

A spokesman for Eversheds said: “The tribunal disagreed with our decision to act to ensure an employee on maternity leave was not disadvantaged. We were surprised by the decision of the tribunal. We stand by the actions that we took and believe that the tribunal’s ruling is mistaken. We will be appealing.”

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1279205/Lawyer-axed-firm-scared-sack-pregnant-colleague.html

More Winston Solicitors news

Client feedback

Very efficient and very pleasant to deal with, highly recommended
Kim
Despite a protected sale, Sidraa & Tom were the consummate professionals and kept everything on track
Kate
I was dreading the probate process after my husband sadly died earlier this year. Friends who had been in the same situation warned me it could take months or even years. I didn't even know what it involved, it was a complete mystery to me!Thank good ness for Emily Spencer at Winston solicitors who talked me through the whole process and told me what information I needed to complete the paperwork. Emails and phone queries were answered very promptly and once I'd submitted all the figures the grant of probate was applied for by Emily and was returned within a few weeks, not months! Great result and nothing like the trauma I was anticipating.
Patricia
Very quick response time and very helpful answering all our questions. Will definitely be using Winston Solicitors again!
Yasmine
Excellent communication and fast efficient service, would recommend them.
Hannah
Really helpful advice
Anonymous
We used Winston's (Samantha) for our house sale & purchase. Very impressed with her dealings with us, keeping us up to date with progress and always happy to answer any questions we had. Nothing was too much trouble for her. Colleagues who asisted her, were equally helpful. Would have no hesitation in using them again or recommend the firm. First class service.
Anonymous
I cannot recommend Winston's highly enough. My case in question was extremely long, convoluted and complex. Yet Winston's and in particular Harriet Reid and Emily Bell, proved to be more than up to the task. Sticking to and sifting through the facts and presenting the evidence, despite volumes of irrelevant information being thrown at them. The results achieved in court, were a true testament to their skill dedication, knowledge and understanding of the subject at hand.
David
Contact us