Legal news

CPS takes no action over boy’s death

Jonathan Winston Jonathan Winston
2 min read

The Crown Prosecution Service has said that staff who gave a five-year-old boy a fatal overdose will not face any criminal charges.

The CPS has written to the family of Bailey Ratcliffe, to say that, after an investigation by West Yorkshire Police and prosecutors, there is insufficient evidence to charge staff at Dewsbury District Hospital with gross negligence manslaughter. Bailey, from Dewsbury, died after being given seven times the correct dose of anti-epileptic drug phenytoin.

The CPS wrote to Bailey’s family to say that it was clear that Bailey’s death was due to the excessive amount of phenytoin which he had been given, that the death was tragic and shocking, but that it was still not possible to charge the individuals responsible.

Alison Storey, reviewing lawyer from the CPS Special Crime Division, said: “The law sets an extremely high evidential hurdle for bringing charges for this offence as the prosecution must prove that individuals caused the death by grossly breaching their duty of care to the person who died. I concluded that it was not possible to prove this to the required standard in this case.”

She said that while a doctor and two nurses had breached their duty of care towards Bailey, it would not be possible to prove that they did so in such a way that their actions became criminal “with such indifference to the obvious and serious risk to Bailey’s life”.

The family have reacted with anger to the news that nobody will be prosecuted for the error, Carrianne Ratcliffe, Bailey’s mother said: “It has destroyed our lives. It's disgusting.”

More Winston Solicitors news

Client feedback

I had approached Winston Solicitors for aid about a time-sensitive case. They were very responsive, both through email and phone, and professional. They helped me resolve my case quickly and with ease.
Anonymous
Used Winstons for the conveyancing of my first property. Leasa, Julie and everyone there were very friendly and helpful throughout keeping me updated and chasing with the sellers solicitors. Excellent firm, I would definitely use them again.
Barnabus
I have used Winston Solicitors a couple of times now during a purchase and Sale of a property. Most recently i have used them for the sale and my main contact was Joe Bright. Joe kept me updated through every part of the process and made the selling of the property less stress than it would have been. I would like to thank Joe and the team for their hard work and support in ensuring the property sale when through as efficiently as possible.
Jhangir
We had an excellent experience throughout the entire process. The team was extremely helpful, informative, and kept us updated at every stage. They were very knowledgeable, particularly regarding our funds coming from Romania, and they were thoroughly involved in all the required checks, which gave us great confidence. Communication was clear, timely, and professional, and we always felt well supported. We are very grateful for their dedication and would not hesitate to recommend their services to others.
Aurora
We have just used Winston Solicitors for any sale which went very well but the purchase had a few problems and took longer than expected but with the help of Sam and her team we finally got there. Sam was very good any problems we had were dealt with correctly and straight away acted on which was good professional work always. We would definitely use them again and recommend them.
Michael
I was highly recommended to this firm, though initially I was hesitant to work with someone so far away. Any doubts I had, however, were quickly dispelled—everything progressed satisfactorily.Throughout the process, Monika and her team were highly professional and kept me informed online at every stage. Their work was carried out efficiently and to our satisfaction.Thank you, Monika, for your outstanding support throughout this process. I will definitely reach out to you and Winston Solicitors again for any future needs.Sid
Sid
I recently used Winston Solicitors for the puchace of a new house and I don't have anything other than positive things to say obout the service. Olivia was always availble when I needed to get in touch for updates, either by phone or email. The level of customer service really shone through and that's what I would say made the difference. I'd have no hesitation in recommending them to anyone who is looking for a conveyencing solicitor.
Matt
My family and I had a great experience with Winston’s. The staff are friendly, efficient, and answer emails in a timely fashion. Monika who dealt with our case was approachable and explained things in a way that was easy for the lay person to understand. She also kept us updated regularly, which was appreciated.
Catherine
Contact us