Couple forced to pay out ridiculous £20,000 over “minor accident” to neighbour | Winston Solicitors Skip to main content
Legal news

Couple forced to pay out ridiculous £20,000 over “minor accident” to neighbour

Jonathan Winston Jonathan Winston
1 min read

A couple from Prestwich, Manchester have been forced to pay out £20,000 in damages after a former neighbour sustained injuries in a minor accident outside their home.

Brendan Hodgkiss and his partner Cynthia Parker were ordered to pay the damages at Salford County Court after Foroozan Panahandeh said she suffered injuries when some plastic guttering fell onto her from three feet as she was putting out her bins. She then took out a negligence claim against her neighbours claiming that she had sustained injuries to her neck, left shoulder and knee. The action was also against Salford City Council who had owned the property at the time of the incident, though the couple later bought it under the right to buy scheme.

However a civil action against the local authority was discontinued and the judge ordered that the couple pay the £20,000 of which only £3,000 is expected to go to Ms Panahandeh with the rest being taken up by legal fees. The couple offered to pay the money back at £50 a month but the woman’s solicitors have rejected this as they say it would take 34 years for the debt to be repaid.

The couple say they are still unsure how they will pay the amount owed and they may have to resort to selling their home.

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/newstopics/howaboutthat/8714036/Couple-sued-by-neighbour-for-20000-over-minor-accident-outside-house.html

Client feedback

Not a first time buyer but this was my first experience with Winston Solicitors and it was fantastic. Sidraa was my solicitor and she has been beyond brilliant. She has been outstanding. She has delivered an excellent service. She has dealt with inquiries promptly and efficiently and made the house transaction go smoothly. Thank you very much Sidraa and also, a special thank you to Tom McIlroy and the team at Winston Solicitors. Professional and efficient service from the start to completion, I would highly recommend them.
Anonymous
Leasa and Julie are fully professional and lovely to speak to over the phone. Very clear with the information given even to myself who has no idea about anything on the legal side of selling a property. Would highly recommend and will be using again for my house purchase.
Jack
I used Winston solicitors for the first time, to handle the sale of my property, on recommendation from my property agent. The conveyancing was done by Sidraa Razaq, who was assisted by Tom Mcillroy. I am delighted by their service. They were proessional in their communications and extremely efficient. I was kept informed at all times during the sale process, which was concluded with minimum fuss and disruption. I am very happy to recommend them and endorse their services.
Jatinder
I found the process easy to follow and was clearly informed of progress at all stages. - February 2025
K O'Connor, Leeds
Leasa and Julie were excellent in helping my partner and I buy our first home. They set out expectations in the first instance, and kept us updated, and it felt as though they really were on our side throughout. Thank you! - February 2025
Patrick S, Tadcaster
We were recommended Winstons by a family member who had used them.It was a fantastic recommendation.Leasa and the team supported us through our sale and purchase of a new property. We never needed to chase them, everything was done in a very timely manner and they were all extremely helpful.We have already recommended Winston's to another family member.
Hannah
I could not have asked for a better solicitor to help me through the process of buying my first house. Nothing was too much trouble and everything was so simple, clear and thorough. Incredibly professional and organised from start to finish. Winston Solicitors have made what could have been a very daunting and difficult process as smooth as it could have been and I would recommend them to anyone! Thank you Lease and team!
Peter
Excellent, friendly and professional service, great communication throughout, would highly recommend.
Ms L