Can you stop your employee joining a competitor | Winston Solicitors Skip to main content
dispute resolution three people looking at document
Advice

Can you stop your employee joining a competitor

Samira Cakali Samira Cakali
3 min read

Employers often seek to protect their business interests by including non-compete restrictive covenants in employment contracts for senior staff members. These clauses prohibit the employee from working for a competitor or establishing a competing business for a defined period after termination. However, the law surrounding non-compete clauses is part of English common law and is subject to development by the courts on a case-by-case basis.

The Government launched a consultation between 04 December 2020 and 26 February 2021 to reform the law on non-compete restrictive covenants. This was following the economic impact of the Covid-19 pandemic where the Government was exploring the option of restricting the use of restrictive covenants in order to maximise opportunities for individuals to start new businesses and find new work.  On 02 March 2022 it was announced that the Government’s response would be published “in due course” but no timeframe was provided and the response is still awaited.  The Government sought views on two proposals:

  1. banning restrictive covenants altogether;
  2. a requirement for employers to pay compensation in return for the restrictive covenant if they want to stop a departing employee from joining a competing business, or banning such clauses altogether.

In California, non-compete clauses are void, regardless of whether they are reasonable, while in Israel, the courts have limited the enforceability of non-compete clauses. Although the success of these international examples is based on various factors, their innovative approach to non-compete clauses should not be discarded as playing a part.

At Winston Solicitors, we regularly advise clients on the use of non-compete clauses and other restrictive covenants to protect their business interests. While these clauses are commonly included in contracts of employment for senior staff, they are also frequently used as part of settlement terms in settlement agreements.

The legal principles surrounding non-compete clauses form part of the doctrine of restraint of trade. The courts have recognised the tension in this area between an individual's freedom to trade and the need to uphold contracts and protect legitimate interests as part of a contract. The court's task is to balance these competing aspects of public policy. The law presumes that all non-compete clauses and other restraints of trade are unenforceable unless they are shown to be reasonable.

To be considered reasonable and enforceable, a non-compete clause must protect a legitimate business interest of the ex-employer and not be wider than reasonably necessary to protect that interest. The employer bears the burden of proving reasonableness in both respects. Therefore, a non-compete clause is only enforceable if an employer can prove to the court that it is reasonably necessary to protect its legitimate business interest. If the court is not persuaded, the non-compete clause is unenforceable.
If an employer successfully enforces a non-compete clause, the employer may seek an injunction or damages from the employee for breaching the covenant or pursue other remedies.

In the post-Covid world and whilst the Government’s response to its consultation is awaited, it remains to be seen whether non-compete clauses will continue to be a typical feature of employment contracts for senior staff or part of settlement terms in settlement agreements.

If you require legal advice regarding non-compete clauses or other restrictive covenants, please do not hesitate to contact Winston Solicitors. Our team of employment law experts is here to assist you with all your employment law needs.

Client feedback

Our company M-Integrated Solutions PLC  (and other subsidiaries) has worked with Paul Grindley for many years. Paul is a very professional gentleman who is always available, and provides solid 360 degree advice on Employment Law. Paul’s professional guidance and advice over the last 14 months during COVID has been absolutely invaluable. We would be delighted to recommend Paul to any company looking for solid advice in and around Employment Law.
Jim Curley, London
 Paul Grindley has provided us with advice on employment law for the past 15 years. His professional approach and vast experience always makes us feel we are in very safe hands regardless of the query.  Paul goes the extra mile in understanding the business needs  and therefore has always provided us with reassurance of a problem quickly.   During COVID Winston Solicitors has also provided us with regular employment law updates which we have found to be extremely useful.    
Cyan Studios Ltd, Leeds
Paul was extremely helpful and efficient. He was professional in every way and got the job done. Many thanks. I would highly recommend
Catherine
Very knowledgable. Gave great advice. Responded to emails swiftly and was generous with time on the phone.
Wayne
I am very satisfied with the service that I have received. Hugh and Paul have always been prompt in their responses and diligent in their work. I have very much appreciated their support during the past few months.
Paul Connor, Leeds
Prompt professional service
Jolene
I've used Winston solicitors a couple of times now and have found them very efficient and knowledgeable. In each case, everything was explained in layman's terms and unlike some other firms, the meter didn't start running as soon as you picked up the phone. Highly recommend.
Jonathan
Paul Grindley has provided us with advice on employment law for the past 15 years.  His professional approach and vast experience always makes us feel we are in very safe hands regardless of the query.  Paul goes the extra mile in understanding the business needs and employees, and therefore has always provided us with reassurance of a problem quickly.   During COVID Winston Solicitors has also provided us with regular employment law updates which we have found to be extremely useful.  
Adele Flesher Cyan Studios Limited, Leeds